CASTING OFF

Lucky’s Hot Wings

Choose your sauce! Buffalo Style, BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Old Bay, Sweet Chili Thai, Garlic Teriyaki, Sesame Teriyaki, Honey Habenero, and “Somebody Call 911” - $14

*There will be a $2 upcharge for all flats/all drums and $1 for daytona style.

Southern Fried Shrimp

Served with our famous Lucky sauce! $16

spinach & artichoke Dip  

Served with tortilla chips $12

Crunchy Tender Calamari

Dusted with grated black pepper Parmesan and served with marinara $12

Bacon Wrapped Sea Scallops

Sea scallops wrapped in bacon on a bed of crispy onion strings, drizzled with Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ $18

Sweet Onion Hush Puppies

$5

Capt Tony’s Favorite Hot Crab Dip

Served with sliced pretzel bread and topped with bronzed pecans $16

fit Bites* 

Choose grilled tenderloin steak with horseradish mayo or blackened tuna with bistro mustard $12

Tuna Poke 

Marinated Ahi tuna with seaweed salad, jasmine rice, and crispy wontons $12

Lucky’s Best Ever Nachos* 

Blackened tuna or chicken, corn tortilla chips, shredded lettuce, melted cheese, salsa, scallions, and sour cream (Add guacamole - $1) $16

drunken shrimp

Sauteed shrimp in a garlic-shallot bourbon cream sauce. Served with toasted baguettes $16

Shrimp Scampi Flatbread - *NEW*

Marinated garlic lemon shrimp with scampi sauce, carmelized onions, and mozzerella & parmesan cheeses *LIMITED AVAILABILITY DAILY* $15

steamers

Seafood Platters are garnished with Old Bay Seasoning

Peel and eat shrimp are NOT deveined

No substitutions please

Middle NECK CLAMS*

A dozen, available steamed or raw $15

Steamed SHrimp and Veggies

One pound of peel and eat shrimp with seasonal veggies $18

Half pound $10

Steamed Combo*

Oysters, clams, shrimp, mussels, and seasonal veggies $25

SOUPS & SALADS

The Original Wedge* 

Iceberg lettuce, diced tomatoes, bacon, red onion, cucumber, Bleu cheese crumbles, and Bleu cheese dressing $10
 

Crispy Oyster Caesar*

Lightly fried oysters on romaine lettuce with classic Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, and croutons $18
 

Fresh Seafood Cobb Salad 

Garden greens, bacon, shredded cheese, egg, cucumber, and avocado topped with chilled bay shrimp, blackened bay scallops, and fresh crab meat $17
 

Blackened Chicken Salad*

Cajun spiced chicken on garden greens with goat cheese, black bean corn salsa, egg, tomato, and grapes, topped with onion strings $15

Add/Sub Protein - MARKET PRICE

Chicken, Calamari, Oysters, Shrimp, Tuna, Steak, Salmon

Greek Islands Calamari Salad* 

Fried calamari rings on garden greens with Kalamata olives, diced tomatoes, artichoke hearts, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini, red onions, and Greek Feta dressing $16

Grilled salmon Salad* 

Grilled salmon over baby spinach with roasted butternut squash, goat cheese, bacon, and honey roasted pecans $20

Lucky’s Oyster Stew* 

A house specialty prepared to order with bacon, onions and celery $12

Creamy She Crab Soup - *NEW* 

A NEW house recipe! $10

New England Clam Chowder

A classic creamy recipe (made with bacon) $8

DINNERS FROM THE FARM

Served with a garden or Caesar salad

Add mushrooms, bleu cheese crumbles, or a fried egg to any steak for $1/each

Sizzlin’ Steak Combo*

Grilled 8oz sirloin paired with fried shrimp or a broiled crabcake. Served with one side item.  $32

Lucky’s House Sirloin*  

8 oz Prime Sirloin, served with one side item. $25

fire grilled ribeye* 

10 oz Ribeye.  Served with one side item. $30

Pungo Farm chicken fried Chicken

Fried organic chicken breast over garlic mashers and green beans, smothered in homemade gravy $16

DINNERS FROM THE BEACH

Served with a garden or Caesar salad and one side item

Broiled Neptune’s Feast

Crab stuffed shrimp, scallops, oysters Rockafeller, and fresh fish topped with shrimp scampi sauce $32
*No substitutions please

Crabcake Dinner

Available broiled, grilled, fried, or blackened. $29

Southern Fried Shrimp 

Jumbo Shrimp - lightly fried, served with our famous Lucky Sauce! $20

Flounder Dinner

Our Locals' favorite! $20

Fried Oyster Dinner

Fresh oysters, hand breaded and lightly fried to order $25

fried Outer Banks Platter

Shrimp, scallops, oysters, half crab cake, and fresh fish $32
*No substitutions please

Sea Scallops

Available broiled or fried $28

Lobster and Crab Mac and Cheese

 $22

Seafood au gratin

Lump crab, bay scallops, and bay shrimp in a creamy cheese sauce. Served with a toasted Baguette $26                                                                                  

Everyday CATCH

Everyday Catch* - Market 

Salmon, Tuna, Haddock, Rockfish, Mahi, Flounder, Grouper, Wahoo
Available Grilled, Blackened, Broiled, Fried or Bronzed

Sweet Chili Thai Salmon* 

Grilled salmon over Pina Colada rice, finished with a sweet chili pineapple, pepper, and scallion glaze $24

Wahoo Puttanesca - *NEW* 

Grilled Wahoo topped with crushed tomatoes, kalamata olives, capers, and garlic green beans $24

Lobster Mahi Mahi* 

Lightly blackened Mahi over roasted red pepper jasmine rice and topped with a lobster scampi sauce $27

Rockfish Scampi Trio*

Grilled rockfish topped with bay shrimp, lump crab, and lobster in a creamy scampi sauce over garlic mashed potatoes $26

Tuna oscar* -*NEW* 

Grilled Tuna over garlic mashed potatoes, topped with asparagus, lump crab meat, and Hollandaise sauce $28

tacos and quesadillas

Served with one side item *excludes taco bowls*

Blackened Mahi Quesadilla*

Lightly blackened mahi, shredded cheese, crispy bacon, black bean corn salsa, and scallions $16

Key West Fish Tacos*

Three soft tortillas filled with fresh fish and topped with cheese, lettuce, cabbage, black bean corn salsa, and cilantro lime crema  $16                                                                                       

Barb's taco bowl 

Grilled or fried fish - served over Red Beans and Rice with mixed cheese, lettuce, cabbage, salsa, and cilantro lime crema $15                         

crispy fried rockfish tacos

Three soft tortillas with fried Rockfish, mixed cheese, lettuce, cabbage, black bean corn salsa, and Peppadew aioli. $16

Substitute your protein

Chicken $16 | Shrimp, Tuna $18 | Steak, Mahi $20

BEACH BASKETS

Crispy Oyster Basket

Served with tartar and cocktail $18

Southern Fish Fry

Served with tartar and cocktail $14

Subsitute flounder $17

The Treble Hook

Oysters, shrimp, and flounder. Served with tartar, cocktail, and lucky  $19

Crispy Fried Shrimp

Served with Lucky sauce $14

Chicken Tenders

Served with ranch and honey mustard $12
 

BEACH BURGERS & SANDWICHES

Served with one side. Add a garden or Caesar salad for $4

Dave's Bordelaise smash burger*

A double stack of Angus beef with American cheese, crispy onion strings, and Bordelaise sauce $12

Crab Burger*

Topped with sautéed Crab meat and melted Provolone cheese, with lettuce tomato, and pickle $16

Cheeseburger in Paradise

Angus beef patty with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and pickle $11

Add bacon, onion, mushrooms, or haystack onions to any item for $1/each

Florida Grouper Sandwich 

Blackened Florida grouper topped with homemade cole slaw and zesty peppadew aioli $17

the Sola Burger*

Topped with garlic white cheddar cheese, grilled shrimp, and chipotle aioli. With lettuce, tomato, and pickle $18
$1 from each sale will be donated to fund Pancreatic Cancer research

Crabcake sandwich

Available grilled, blackened, broiled or fried. Served with lettuce, tomato, and pickle $17

Flounder BLT

Fried flounder, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, pickle, and coleslaw $14

french dip 

Shaved steak, provolone cheese, and caramelized onions on a toasted hoagie roll.  Served with a cup of Au Jus $14                      

Chicken melt

Grilled chicken with crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickle, and a drizzle of ranch $12

Spicy Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Fried chicken tossed in Frank's Hot Sauce, topped with Bleu cheese crumbles, onion strings, lettuce, tomato, and pickle $14

Blackened Mahi Sandwich*

Blackened mahi, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, pickle, and cole slaw $16

Knott’s Island Tuna sandwich*

Available grilled or blackened.  Served with lettuce, tomato, and pickle $15

Mike’s Tuna Melt 

House made tuna salad blended with old bay, celery, and onion on Country White Bread, with cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and pickle  $12

PASTA

Served with a garden or Caesar salad and baguette

Penne Arrabbiata - *NEW*

Bay scallops and shrimp in a spicy chili marinara, topped with parmesan and fresh basil $18

Blackened Chicken & Broccoli Alfredo

Made with penne pasta $16 - with Shrimp $18

Baked Seafood Penne

Bay shrimp, lobster, and lump crab meat baked in a mix of alfredo and marinara sauce, topped with melted Mozzarella and Parmesan $18

DESSERTS

Bourbon Street Bread Pudding

With chopped walnuts and vanilla bean ice cream, topped with whipped cream andvcaramel $7

Key West Key Lime Pie

With Nellie and Joe’s Key Lime juice in a Graham cracker crust. Topped with whipped cream and lime zest $6

Mango guava cheesecake

Topped with almond slices and whipped cream $8

Chocolate Volcano Cake

With vanilla bean ice cream, topped with chocolate syrup, caramel, and whipped cream $7

Lucky’s Famous “Mile High” Carrot Cake

With raisins, walnuts, pineapple, and velvety cream cheese icing $11

Molten Chocolate Chip Cookie

Warm cookie with vanilla bean ice cream, topped with chocolate syrup $8

sides

Key West Cole Slaw GF $3
Red Beans N’ Rice GF $3
French Fries $4
Green Beans GF $5

  Steamed Broccoli GF $4
 Sweet Potato Waffle Fries $4
                 4 Cheese Mac N' Cheese $6                                    Sauteed Asparagus GF $6                   Garlic Potato Wedges $5

Baked Potato
(available after 4:00pm) GF $4
Loaded add $1!
Garlic Mashers GF $4

Extra Sauces $0.50/ea

kid's menu $6

Includes Fountain Drink, Milk or Juice

Served with choice of

French Fries, Sweet Fries, Applesauce, Mashed Potatoes

Mac n' Cheese, or steamed Broccoli

Grilled Cheese

Popcorn Shrimp

Chicken Fingers (Fried or Grilled)

Lucky's Cheeseburger

Mac n' Cheese

Fish n' Chips

Pasta (Marinara or Alfredo)

Mozzarella Cheese Stix

Receive your Kid's meal on a Lucky Oyster Logo Frisbee

for only $2.50 more!

We proudly serve coke products:

                                    Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Sprite, Minute Maid Lemonade,                                   Hi-C Fruit Punch, Fanta Orange, Powerade Mountain Berry Blast, Seagram's Gingerale, and Dr. Pepper
 

We also serve freshly brewed sweet and unsweet tea, Saratoga Sparkling Water, Segafredo coffee, and IBC bottled Root Beer

LUCKY'S GEAR

T-shirts $20
Long Sleeve T's $25
                 Hoodies $40                     Camo Hoodies $55-$60
Hats $22-$30

Kid's T-shirts $12
Crew Neck Sweatshirts $35
Kid's Hoodies $28
Island Salt Scrub $25