CASTING OFF
Lucky’s Hot Wings
One pound of Buffalo’s finest hot wings!
Buffalo Style, BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Old Bay, Sweet Chile Thai, Garlic Teriyaki, Honey-Habenero, and “Somebody Call 911”
12.99
Southern Fried Shrimp
8 crispy butterflied shrimp with our own Lucky Sauce!
Try ‘em Buffalo Style!
12.99
spinach & artichoke Dip - *new*
Fresh made - served with toasted Baguettes
11.99
Crunchy Tender Calamari
Crispy Calamari dusted with grated Parmesan and black pepper served with rustic Marinara.
11.99
Bacon Wrapped Sea Scallops
Four delicious sea scallops wrapped with crispy bacon served with Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce over crispy onion strings.
15.99
Crab rangoon - *new*
Four crispy fried Crab and Cream cheese filled pockets, served with Sweet Chili Thai dipping sauce
14.99
Capt Tony’s Favorite Hot Crab Dip
The Local’s favorite! Served with sliced Pretzel bread and topped with chopped Bronzed pecans
15.99
Tenderloin Steak Bites* 
Fire Grilled tenderloin bites served with our zesty Horseradish sauce
12.99
Blackened Tuna Bites*
Fresh caught tuna lightly blackened and served with our own Lucky’s Bistro sauce
12.99
Oysters Rockefeller*
8 large, delicious Eastern Shore Oysters with spinach, crumbled bacon, and melted cheese
15.99
Lucky’s Best Ever Nachos*
Blackened Tuna or Chicken, nacho chips, shredded lettuce, melted cheese, salsa, scallions, and sour cream. Add guacamole - .99cents
14.99
Tuna Poke
Marinated Ahi Tuna with Hawaiian Seaweed Salad over Jasmine rice topped with Wonton strips and Sesame seeds
11.99
LUCKY'S RAW BAR
Seafood Platters are garnished with Old Bay Seasoning
Chesapeake Bay Oysters*
A full dozen, shucked to order, steamed, or on the half shell.
16.99
Warning: Fresh Oysters may contain bits of shell
Eastern Shore Clams*
A full dozen Middle Neck clams, steamed or on the half shell
14.99
Steamed Shrimp N’ Vegetable Platter
A heaping helping of fresh shrimp and seasonal vegetables served with Hollandaise and cocktail sauce 17.99
Half Order 10.79
Lucky’s Large Steamed Combo*
Steamed oysters, clams, shrimp, mussels, and Seasonal vegetables
22.99
*NO SUBSTITUTIONS PLEASE
LUCKY'S MARINA - dINE IN ONLY
OYSTERS, CLAMS, MUSSELS, SHRIMP, CRAB LEGS, and Seasonal vegetables
A heaping helping of Southern Hospitality...
Today’s best catch - steamed and piled high on a giant platter
Served with a basket of Hush Puppies
LARGE (serves 6-8) Market
SMALL (serves 2-4) Market
*NO SUBSTITUTIONS PLEASE
Warning: Fresh Oysters may contain bits of shell
SOUPS & SALADS
The Original Wedge*
A crisp wedge of iceberg lettuce with tomatoes, bacon, onions, cucumbers, crumbled bleu cheese, and Bleu cheese dressing - 9.99
Chicken - 12.99, Tuna* - 14.99, or Calamari - 13.99
Crispy Oyster Caesar*
Lightly fried Oysters with fresh Romaine lettuce, classic Caesar dressing, shredded Parmesan cheese, and fresh baked croutons - 14.99
Chicken 12.99, Tuna* 15.99, Shrimp 14.99
Fresh Seafood Cobb Salad
The seafood lovers salad! Blackened Bay Scallops, fresh crab meat, and Chilled Bay shrimp together with crispy bacon, mixed cheeses, tomatoes, sliced egg, cucumber, and sliced avocado over fresh garden greens - 16.99
Blackened Chicken Salad*
Zesty Cajun spiced grilled chicken on Garden greens, creamy goat cheese, black bean corn salsa, sliced eggs, tomatoes and fresh grapes topped with crispy onion strings - 12.99 Try it with Grilled Steak* - 15.99
The Greek Islands Calamari Salad*
Crunchy tender Calamari, garden greens, Kalamata olives, diced tomatoes, Artichoke hearts, Garbanzo beans, Pepperoncinis, red onions, Feta cheese, and our classic Greek dressing - 12.99
Chicken 12.99, Shrimp 14.99, Tuna* 15.99
Lucky’s Oyster Stew*
A House Specialty! Prepared to order with crumbled bacon, onions, and celery
7.99
Creamy She Crab Soup
A Chesapeake Bay tradition - made fresh daily
7.99
New England Clam Chowder
Classic creamy Clam Chowder with bacon 6.99
Salad Dressings: Homemade Ranch, Dijon Vinaigrette, Pepper Parmesan, Bleu Cheese, Honey Mustard, Balsamic Vinaigrette, 1000 Island, French, Greek Vinaigrette, Lite Italian
DINNERS FROM THE FARM
Served with a Garden or Caesar salad
Sizzlin’ Steak Combos*
Fire Grilled House Sirloin paired with either our signature Fried Shrimp or Chesapeake Bay broiled Crab Cake, served with one Southern Style Side
27.99
Lucky’s House Sirloin*
8 oz Prime Sirloin, Fire Grilled and seasoned to perfection, served with one Southern Style Side
18.99
Add mushrooms, Bleu cheese crumbles or a fried egg for .99 cents
fire grilled ny strip*
Our tender 12 oz NY Strip - finished with roasted Garlic, caramelized onions and sauteed mushrooms, served over Garlic mashers
34.99
Grilled Steaks are finished with seasoned butter
Pungo Farm chicken fried Chicken
Large Coleman Chicken breast, hand breaded and smothered in home made gravy. Served with Garlic mashers and sauteed Green Beans
15.99
MEDIUM RARE
cool pink
center
MEDIUM
warm pink
center
MEDIUM WELL
thin pink
center
WELL DONE
overcooked
DINNERS FROM THE BEACH
Served with one Southern Style Side and a Salad
“Neptune’s” Feast
Broiled Crab Stuffed shrimp, broiled Scallops, Oysters Rockafeller, and fresh fish finished with a Bay Shrimp scampi sauce.
32.99
*No substitutions please
Miss Pam’s Broiled Crabcake Dinner
From a classic Eastern Shore recipe - broiled to perfection! Also available grilled or fried. You won’t taste a better crabcake anywhere!
Market
Southern Fried Shrimp Dinner -Our Specialty!
Jumbo Shrimp - lightly fried, served with our famous Lucky Sauce!
16.99
Flounder Dinner
Our Local’s favorite - fresh Flounder - lightly fried to a golden crunch
17.99
Fried Oyster Dinner - Lucky’s Favorite!
Fresh oysters, hand breaded and lightly fried to order
21.99
“The Outer Banks” Platter
A generous platter of shrimp, scallops, oysters, crab cake, and fresh fish - lightly fried to a golden brown
32.99
*No substitutions please
Broiled Or Crunch Fried Sea Scallops
Lightly seasoned Sea Scallops baked in butter or flash fried to a delicate crisp
25.99
Lobster and Crab Mac and Cheese
Creamy Panko Parmesan encrusted Mac and Cheese with a generous helping of Lobster and Chesapeake Bay crab
18.99
Shrimp and crawfish Etouffee
Grilled Shrimp and Crawfish tails in a zesty Creole sauce with garlic, peppers and onions over Jasmine rice
21.99
Crab Stuffed Flounder
Broiled Flounder fillet, stuffed with our Chesapeake Bay Crabcake, finished with a creamy Scampi sauce
24.99
FRESH CATCH
Everyday Fresh Catch* - Market
Salmon, Tuna, Haddock, Rockfish, Mahi, Flounder, Grouper
Available Grilled, Blackened, Broiled, Fried or Bronzed
Check our Chalkboards for “Fresh Catch Additions”
Sweet Chile Thai Salmon*
Fire Grilled Salmon over Pina Colada rice finished with a Sweet Thai pineapple, pepper, and scallion glaze
23.99
cajun grouper - *new*
Lightly blackened Florida Grouper over Garlic mashers, finished with our zesty Crawfish Etouffee sauce
24.99
Lobster Mahi Mahi*
Lightly blackened Mahi Mahi with a creamy Lobster sauce over Roasted Red Pepper Jasmine Rice
24.99
Rockfish Scampi Trio
Grilled Rockfish topped with Bay shrimp, Crab, and Lobster in a creamy Scampi sauce over Truffle mashers
25.99
Bronzed Tuna Tostada*
Fresh Tuna over a crispy Blue Corn tortilla shell and Red Beans and Rice, layered with Goat cheese, salsa, scallions, and a drizzle of Cilantro Lime Crema
22.99
All items served with a Garden or Caesar salad
tacos and quesadillas
Blackened Mahi Quesadilla*
Fresh, lightly blackened Mahi, mixed cheese, crispy bacon, black bean corn salsa, and scallions. Served with one Southern Style side. 15.99
Key West Fish Tacos*
Three soft tortilla shells filled with fresh fish. Served with cheese, lettuce, cabbage, fresh salsa, and a drizzle of Cilantro Lime Crema. Served with one Southern Style. 15.99 Substitute Shrimp or Tuna - 16.99 / Mahi, Flounder or Steak - 17.99
Barb's fresh catch taco bowl
Grilled or fried Fresh catch - served over Red Beans and Rice with mixed cheese, lettuce, cabbage, salsa, and Cilantro Lime Crema. 14.99 Substitute Flounder, Tuna, Shrimp, Steak, Chicken or Mahi 17.99
crispy fried rockfish tacos
Warm soft tortillas with lightly fried Rockfish, mixed cheese, lettuce, cabbage, black bean corn salsa, and Peppadew aioli. Served with one Southern Style. 14.99
BEACH BASKETS
Crispy Oyster Basket
Select Eastern Shore oysters, lightly breaded and flash fried - the Best of the Beach! Served with Tartar and Cocktail
16.99
Southern Fish Fry
Fresh catch, crunch fried in our traditional Southern Style. Served with Tartar and Cocktail. Try it with fresh Flounder - 13.99
12.99
The Treble Hook
Your 3 favorites - Oysters, Fresh Fish, and Southern fried Shrimp. Served with Tartar, Cocktail, and Lucky Sauce
18.99
Crispy Fried Shrimp
Jumbo fried shrimp served with Lucky Sauce and Cocktail
12.99
Chicken Tenders
Crispy chicken tenders served with House Made Ranch and Honey Mustard
10.99
Baskets are served over your choice of crispy French Fries or Sweet potato Fries
Add a Garden or Caesar salad for 3.99
Warning: Fresh Oysters may contain bits of shell
BEACH BURGERS & SANDWICHES
Served with your choice of one Southern Style side. Add a Garden or Caesar salad for 3.99
Dave's Bordelaise smash burger*
A double stack of Angus beef with melted American cheese, crispy Cajun onion strings, and a drizzle of Bordelaise
12.99
Old Bay Blue Crab Burger*
Lucky’s classic cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato, and pickles topped with sautéed Crab meat and melted Provolone cheese
14.99
Bacon Cheeseburger in Paradise
Fire grilled Angus beef burger with melted Cheddar, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato and pickles
12.99
Florida Grouper Sandwich -*new*
Fresh blackened Florida Grouper topped with homemade Cole Slaw and zesty Peppadew Aioli
15.99
“The Warrior” Burger*
Fire grilled Angus beef burger with melted Prvolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and pickles topped with our grilled Crabcake
$1.00 from every “Warrior Burger” sold will go to benefit the Wounded
Warrior Project and The Navy Seal Foundation.
17.99
Miss Pam’s Chesapeake Bay Crabcake
From an authentic Eastern Shore recipe, available grilled, blackened, broiled or fried. Served with lettuce, tomato, and pickles
16.99
Flounder BLT-Locals’ Favorite
Fried Flounder, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and coleslaw
12.99
french dip -*new*
Classic French Dip with shaved steak, melted Provolone cheese and caramelized onions on a fresh baked Hoagie roll with Au Jus.
14.99
Chicken bacon ranch cheddar melt
Fire Grilled Coleman chicken with crispy bacon, red onion, melted Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and a creamy Ranch sauce
11.99
Spicy Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Southern fried, all white Coleman chicken breast tossed with Lucky’s special Buffalo sauce, melted bleu cheese crumbles, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and crispy onion strings
12.99
Blackened Mahi Sandwich*
Blackened Mahi Mahi over fresh Cole Slaw, lettuce, pickles, and tomato. Topped with crispy bacon
15.99
Knott’s Island Tuna*
Fresh Tuna, grilled or blackened with lettuce, pickles, and tomato. Try it with melted cheese .99cents
12.99
Mike’s Tuna Melt
Fresh made Tuna Salad blended with Old Bay spices, lettuce, tomato, pickles, red onion, and bacon with melted Cheddar cheese on toasted Hearty Country white
11.99
Garlicky Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Garlic butter toasted Hearty Country white with melty Provolone, Cheddar, and American cheeses
9.99
Our Angus burgers are served on fresh baked Brioche rolls or choose a Gluten free bun for .99 cents
Add Onions, Haystack Onion Strings, Sauteed Mushrooms, Cheese, Bacon, Avocado, Fried Egg - .99 cents
Substitute a high Protein Beyond Burger on any Beach Burgers -
PASTA
Served with toasted Italian bread and a salad
Chicken Parmesan Bake
Grilled Coleman Chicken smothered in melted Provolone cheese and homemade Rustic Marinara over Penne pasta
14.99
Blackened Chicken & Broccoli Alfredo
Blackened chicken with fresh broccoli in a creamy Alfredo sauce
15.99 - with Shrimp 17.99
Baked Seafood Penne
Bay Shrimp, sweet Lobster, and Chesapeake Crab baked in a blended Alfredo - Marinara sauce with melted Mozzarella and Parmesan
17.99
DESSERTS
Bourbon Street Bread Pudding
Our authentic New Orleans recipe with chopped walnuts, Vanilla Bean ice cream, and a drizzle of warm caramel.
6.59
Key West Key Lime Pie
A Key west favorite - made with Nellie and Joe’s Key Lime juice, nestled into a homemade Graham cracker crust and topped with fresh whipped cream
5.99
Jaq's gluten free chocolate torte
Rich dark chocolate torte with whipped cream and a Raspberry drizzle
6.29
Chocolate Volcano Cake
Molten Chocolate cake with Vanilla Bean ice cream, topped with Hot fudge and Caramel
6.79
Lucky’s Famous “Mile High” Carrot Cake
Moist carrot cake loaded with raisins, walnuts, and pineapple topped with smooth cream cheese icing.
10.99
Seasonal Chef’s Selection - Market Price
Key West Cole Slaw GF 2.99
Red Beans N’ Rice GF 2.99
French Fries 3.79
Green Beans GF 3.99
Steamed Broccoli GF 3.99
Sweet Potato Fries 3.99
Four Cheese Mac N' Cheese 4.29 Garlic Steak Fries 3.99
Jumbo Baked Potato
(available after 4:00pm) GF 4.29
Loaded add .75 cents!
Garlic Mashers GF 3.99
kid's menu
Served with a side choice of -
French Fries, Sweet Fries, Applesauce, Chips or steamed Broccoli
Grilled Cheese
Popcorn Shrimp
Chicken Fingers (Fried or Grilled)
Lucky's Cheeseburger
Mac n' Cheese
Fish n' Chips
Pasta (Marinara or Alfredo)
Mozzarella Cheese Stix
Receive your Kid's meal on a Lucky Oyster Logo Frisbee
for only $2.50 more!
LUCKY'S GEAR
T-shirts 20.00
Long Sleeve T's 25.00
Hoodies 37.00
Hats 22.00-25.00
Kid's T-shirts 12.00
Crew Neck Sweatshirts 30.00
Kid's Hoodies 28.00
Island Salt Scrub 24.95
Check out our entire retail area including Glassware, Koozies, Frisbees, and more!
Gift Cards available for any occasion
For your convenience, an 18% gratuity will be added to parties of 7 or more.
Locally Owned and Operated since 2007
Catering and General Manager - Cheryl Kantirakis
Executive Chef - Dave Horner
* Consuming raw or under cooked meats, eggs, or seafood may increase your risk of food borne illness